Self-Driving Car Accidents in Utah: Who Is Responsible Under Utah’s New Law?
If a car with no one driving it hits you, who do you go after? It’s a fair question, and until recently Utah didn’t have a clear answer.
Now it has a law. It treats the most automated cars differently from regular ones, and it puts some limits on what injured people can recover. Here’s what it says, how it fits with the rest of Utah’s rules, and what to do if you’re hurt in a crash involving a self-driving or driver-assist car.
Most “self-driving” cars still have a driver
The term “self-driving” gets used for very different technology. Federal safety regulators use six levels, from 0 to 5. You can see them on the NHTSA automated vehicles page.
| Level | What the car does | Who is responsible for driving |
|---|---|---|
| 0 to 1 | Little or no help, maybe cruise control or lane warnings | The driver |
| 2 | Helps with steering and speed at the same time | The driver, who must stay alert |
| 3 | Drives itself in certain conditions, asks the driver to take over | The system, until it hands back |
| 4 | Drives itself in a limited area or set of conditions, no human needed | The system |
| 5 | Drives itself everywhere | The system |
NHTSA’s page says Level 2 means the driver must stay “fully engaged and attentive.” It also says there’s no vehicle currently for sale to consumers that is fully self-driving. Most of the “Autopilot” and “self-driving” features on cars people can buy today are Level 2, which means the person in the seat is still the driver.
Level 4 and 5 systems do exist, mostly in fleets like robotaxis and test vehicles. That’s where Utah’s new rules matter most.
The level decides which rules apply, so one of the first questions in any of these cases is how much of the driving the car was doing.
What Utah’s new law says
In 2026, Utah passed Senate Bill 292, which took effect May 6, 2026. It does a few main things.
It names the “operator.”
Under Utah Code § 41-26-104, when an automated driving system is engaged, the system is treated as the operator for following traffic and motor vehicle laws. For a Level 3 system that asks a person to take over, the system stays responsible until it disengages. For Levels 4 and 5, it stays responsible until a human actually starts driving.
It creates a “driverless operation” claim.
Under § 78B-4-903, if a Level 4 or 5 system was engaged and doing all of the driving, an injured person can bring a claim without proving that anyone was negligent or that the system was defective. They have to show the system was engaged and was a proximate cause of the harm. The people who can be sued under this section are the registered owner of the vehicle or the company that sent it out on the road, such as an on-demand autonomous vehicle network.
There’s a big catch. Recovery under this section is limited to **$100,000 total**, including damages, costs, and fees. The amount can also be reduced if you or someone else shares fault.
It caps some damages.
Under § 78B-4-902, noneconomic damages, like pain and suffering, are capped at $1,000,000 in cases involving these systems. The cap does not apply to wrongful death claims. For Level 4 and 5 systems, punitive damages aren’t allowed.
It limits claims against manufacturers.
Under § 78B-4-904, a company that makes or develops a Level 4 or 5 system generally can’t be sued for negligence. Claims have to go through Utah’s product liability law instead. That law has its own rules, including a presumption that a system isn’t defective if it meets federal safety standards and is authorized for use in Utah, and a defense based on the “state of the art.” Those are in § 78B-6-703 and § 78B-6-708.
It expires.
These new liability sections are set to be repealed on July 1, 2030, unless lawmakers extend them.
One thing to know about all this: it’s new. There’s very little court history on how judges will apply it, and summaries online don’t always agree. If you were hurt in a crash involving one of these cars, how the law applies to your situation depends on the details.
Who may be responsible after a crash
Depending on the facts, more than one person or company can be involved.
- Another driver. Plenty of crashes involving automated cars are started by a human driver in another vehicle. Regular negligence rules apply.
- The driver of a Level 2 or Level 3 car. If a person was supposed to be watching the road or taking over and wasn’t, they may share responsibility.
- The owner or the company running the vehicle. For Level 4 and 5 vehicles, this is who the driverless operation section points to.
- The manufacturer or software developer. If a defect in the vehicle or its software caused the crash, a product liability claim may be possible, subject to the extra requirements in the new law.
- Others. A repair shop, a parts maker, or a road or signal problem can play a part too.
Utah divides fault by percentage. Under Utah Code § 78B-5-818, if you’re partly at fault, your compensation is reduced by your share, and if you’re 50% or more at fault, you can’t recover anything. The 2026 law says it doesn’t change that rule.
What the $100,000 limit means in real life
Serious injuries cost a lot. A hospital stay, surgery, and months away from work can pass $100,000 without much trouble. So the limit in the driverless operation section can leave a gap between what someone lost and what that one route pays.
That doesn’t mean there’s nothing else. Other claims may still be possible depending on who was involved and what happened. And your own insurance may matter, since some people have underinsured motorist coverage that applies when other sources fall short.
How these pieces fit together is exactly the kind of question that needs a close look at the facts. We’d rather not guess at it in a blog post.
What evidence matters
In a self-driving car crash, a lot of the key evidence is data, and you usually don’t control it. It can include:
- Software and vehicle logs showing whether the system was engaged
- Camera and sensor recordings
- Alerts or warnings the system gave to a driver
- Maintenance and software update records
- The usual crash evidence, like photos, police reports, witness names, and medical records
Some of it can be overwritten or lost, so a written request asking the company to preserve it can matter. We explain why in our post on truck accident evidence. It’s about trucks, but the idea is the same.
The federal government also tracks some of these crashes. Under NHTSA’s Standing General Order, certain manufacturers and operators have to report specific crashes involving automated driving systems and Level 2 driver-assist systems. That can mean a report exists even if no one told you about it.
Where to go from here
These cases combine new technology with a brand-new law, and the company on the other side usually has more information than you do. Getting help early can make a difference in what evidence is still around.
Our team at Creekside Injury Law works with people across Utah after car accidents, and you can learn more on our Utah car accident lawyer page. We also help people in Logan, Roy, Tooele, and West Valley City.
The technology will keep changing, and so will the law. What doesn’t change is that someone should be answerable when a car on the road hurts someone.
Utah Car Accident Articles
Is Utah a No-Fault State? Here’s What That Actually Means for You
Short answer: yes. Utah is one of a handful of states that runs on a no-fault insurance system. Longer answer: "no-fault" doesn't mean nobody is at fault, and it definitely doesn't mean you're stuck with whatever your own insurance decides to pay. It just changes the...
The Utah UIM Statute: What It Actually Covers and Why It Matters
Picture this: someone runs a red light and slams into your car. It's clearly their fault, and lucky for you, they actually have insurance. Problem solved, right? Not always. Their policy might carry the state minimum, and the state minimum doesn't stretch very far...
What to Do After a Hit and Run in Utah
Getting hit by a car is jarring enough on its own. Having the other driver take off before you can even get their name adds a whole different layer of stress. Now you're dealing with a damaged vehicle, maybe an injury, and no clue who's going to pay for any of it. If...